Bon Levi imprisoned for 10 months following ACCC action for contempt of court
The Federal Court of Australia today sentenced Mr Bon Levi, one of Australia's most notorious conmen, to 10 months' imprisonment, with 6 months suspended, after the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission successfully prosecuted him for five counts of contempt of court.
In handing down the sentence, Justice McKerracher stated that, "Mr Levi has acted in absolute defiance of the court and its orders," and described the conduct as "repeated, serious and flagrant."
ACCC Chairman, Mr Graeme Samuel, welcomed the court's decision.
"The ACCC turns to the court for orders protecting consumers from fraudsters such as Mr Levi," Mr Samuel said.
"When the court's orders are deliberately flouted, it is consumers who are exposed. That is why the ACCC will continue to be vigilant in ensuring the court's authority is upheld, and that those acting in contempt of consumer protection court orders are brought to justice. In extreme cases such as Mr Levi's, that means a jail sentence."
The Federal Court suspended 6 months of Mr Levi's sentence for 5 years on the condition the Mr Levi not sell, advertise or accept any payment for any business opportunity whatsoever, without leave of the court. The court orders also prevent Mr Levi from knowingly participating with any other person in selling business opportunities.
Mr Levi has a long history of defrauding Australians by setting up bogus franchises and businesses that he sells on the promise of guaranteed future earnings.
After the ACCC took successful action against Mr Levi in 2005, Justice Kiefel made orders to protect members of the public dealing with Mr Levi.
Those orders require Mr Levi to provide written disclosure about his history, past aliases and previous breaches of the Trade Practices Act 1974 before accepting payment for any business opportunity or franchise.
"The ACCC acted to protect the public from this recalcitrant conman's repeated attempts to profit from unsuspecting members of the public, who would have been unlikely to do business with Mr Levi if they had known about his fraudulent history," Mr Samuel said.
After the orders were made, the ACCC monitored Mr Levi's activities and responded to numerous complaints about business opportunities and franchises Mr Levi was attempting to sell.
The contempt of court proceedings relate to businesses Mr Levi sold in Melbourne, Sydney and Perth in 2006 and 2007 in defiance of the Federal Court's orders.
The businesses involved included Little Joe Snax snack foods, LPG conversions and
Bikini Girls Massage businesses. In return for $36,000 to $66,000, Mr Levi promised to set up the businesses and pay guaranteed weekly incomes. None of these businesses were ever established and, as a result, consumers lost all their money.
"This case reinforces the need for people to seek legal and financial advice before buying into a franchise or business opportunity," Mr Samuel said. "Consumers should not rush into buying a franchise or a business, and they should be wary of scams promising ways to make a lot of money quickly. Consumers should do their homework about the business itself, as well as the people promoting the business before handing over any money."
For media inquiries to the ACCC Chairman, Mr Graeme Samuel, please call Ms Lin Enright, ACCC Media, on (02) 6243 1108 or 0414 613 520. For general inquiries, please call the Infocentre: 1300 302 502.
To receive information on issues of interest to you, please go to
www.accc.gov.au, click Media Centre, News releases, and enter your email address under Notify me.
The ACCC provides an automatic email alert system whenever there are changes to a page or pages to which you have subscribed.
Release # MR 298/08
Issued: 24th October 2008
Background
After investigating the Little Joe Snax franchise in 2004, the ACCC took Mr Levi to court for breaching the franchising code of conduct, and for misleading or deceptive conduct in relation to the promises he made about the businesses.
On 28 February 2005, Justice Kiefel of the Federal Court of Australia made declarations by consent that Mr Levi had breached section 51AD of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (the Act) in respect of 65 franchise agreements and section 52 of the Act on numerous occasions. Justice Kiefel made orders restraining Mr Levi from selling business opportunities unless he either had (i) run the business successfully for at least 6 months, or (ii) provided a copy of the orders and certain information about his business experience and his aliases to the purchaser. Mr Levi also consented to an order to pay $40,000 to the ACCC in costs.
On 27 September 2006, the Federal Magistrates Court of Australia declared Mr Levi bankrupt after he failed to pay the ACCC $38,000 in costs pursuant to the Federal Court orders.
On 13 June 2007, the ACCC commenced action against Mr Levi for contempt of court. Mr Levi delayed the proceedings by claiming that he could not afford a lawyer to represent him. Immediately prior to the hearing on this application Mr Levi had committed a further contempt of court by selling a Bikini Girls Massage business for $66,000.
On 14 February 2008, Justice Siopis dismissed Mr Levi's application and ordered that Mr Levi stand trial in June 2008. A further attempt by Mr Levi to delay the trial was dismissed and described by Justice Siopis as a strategy by Mr Levi to delay the commencement of his trial for as long as possible.
Mr Levi pleaded guilty to five counts of contempt of court shortly before the trial was to commence.
Aliases previously used by Mr Levi include: Ronald Frederick Heelan, Ronald Frederick, Roddy Farrow, Brett Wyatt, Ronald White and Randy the Wrecker.
Related news releases:
MR 194/07, 27 July 2007, ACCC institutes contempt of court proceedings against Bon Levi.
MR 227/06, 29 September 2006, Court declares Bon Levi bankrupt.
MR 150/04, 6 August 2004, ACCC takes court action against Bon Levi over the sale of Little Joe and Joey's businesses.
MR 057/105, 14 March 2005, Court declares Bon Levi misled franchisees over Little Joe and Joey's businesses.